News from Jeni:

November 22, 2020


Even if you missed out on pre-orders, do not worry.  We will have LOTS of fresh baked stock available for any one who may need early Thanksgiving or "Friendsgiving" treats. We are also offering Jeni's Ugly Pies Gift Cards (hint hint Hostess Gift). Thank you for your kindness, support and patience. We are so THANKFUL for you!


  • Limit # of customers inside at a time to 3 or less

  • Wear a mask - we have some if you forgot yours

  • Call us when you arrive if you prefer curbside service

  • Be patient. We promise we're doing our best to keep you safe AND move quickly. This pertains to phones as well - unfortunately we are not able to monitor the phone during our peak times. 


  • Enter if you are or have been feeling ill

  • Bring extra friends/family inside to shop

  • Ask us to hold or reserve pies for you. ALL retail pies are first-come, first-served.

  • Leave a voicemail asking us to call you back. We are simply not able to return calls during our busiest time of the season.


  • We highly suggest coming after the first hour we are open - this is usually a very high traffic time in the store.

  • Please pick orders up at least one hour prior to store closing

  • Any unclaimed pre-orders will be placed in the freezer at the end of the day Weds Nov. 25. - please contact us during normal business hours the following week to pick-up. No refunds will be issued on unclaimed orders.


Come on in and shop!

We are open and happy to see you - FACE MASKS ARE REQUIRED TO ENTER. If you are not comfortable coming in, give us a call for curbside service!

For Deliveries:

Use the form below to place your order during our pre-order timeframe.  We deliver Thursday and Friday  11a-2p within 8 miles of our bakery.  Minimum $20 order with $5 delivery fee - if you order over $40 we waive the delivery fee.  


ALL PRE-ORDERS MUST BE PLACED USING THE ORDER FORM PROVIDED during our pre-order timeframe or by telephone 10am-2pm Wed-Sat. Website orders must be placed by 9am Tuesday mornings.  If you need a same-day shop, call the bakery between 10-2 Wed-Sat. We do not check the website orders until the end of each business day. We ask that all pre-orders and telephone orders are paid by credit card at time of ordering.


Please do not leave orders on the voicemail or on our Facebook/Instagram pages. 

Menu for Dec 1 - 12

For the next 2 weeks, we will be offering pie orders from our regular pie menu and our Tailgater/Party Provisions Menu below. For Christmas orders, please see our dedicated Christmas page for ordering options and guidelines.

We are working hard to bring you all of your favorites during this very busy time and we are so grateful for you.

December 1 - 12 Orders

Pies & Happiness,

Jeni, Angie, Jean & Julia

Stop in and see us!
1095 S. Milford Rd.
Highland, MI 48357
(248) 534-0556
Business Hours
Sun - Tues:  Closed
Wednesday:  10am - 2pm
Thursday:  10am - 2pm
Friday:  10am - 2pm
Saturday:  10am - 2pm