Pie List
Below you will find a complete list of our Pie & Quiche Flavors.
Please note:
-
Not every flavor listed is available all the time
-
Our best sellers or "Fan Favorites" are the flavors you see most days in the Bakery
-
Some flavors (or variations/sizes) are Pre-Order only
-
Some flavors are Seasonal
-
Sometimes we have a limited/specific Menu (this happens often at Holidays)
-
Sometimes we cannot get the necessary ingredients from our suppliers
-
ALL TIMES we are working our hardest to serve you and accommodate your requests
-
ALL TIMES we appreciate your understanding and kindness
-
NEVER is it OK to treat our Staff poorly because we did not have a flavor you wanted or you forgot to place a Pre-Order. Meanness will not be tolerated. EVER.

Fruit & Nut Pies
Apple $ 18
(crumb or traditional topped)
Blackberry $ 21
(crumb or traditional topped)
Blackberry Chèvre $25
(w/candied almond crumb topping)
Blueberry $ 20
(crumb or traditional topped)
Blueberry Chèvre $ 25
(w/candied almond crumb topping)
Browned Butter Bourbon Pecan $ 25
Caramel Pecan $ 22
(homemade caramel-based pecan pie)
Cherry $ 20
(crumb or lattice topped)
Hawaiian $ 21
(pineapple, mango, papaya with coconut pecan crumb topping)
Highland Beast: Spring/Summer $ 20
(blend of Michigan grown apples, cherries, blueberries and local rhubarb)
Highland Beast: Fall/Winter $ 18
(blend of Michigan grown apples, cherries, blueberries)
Mincemeat (seasonal) $ 18
(traditional topped crust)
Peach $ 18
(crumb or traditional topped)
Pumpkin - fresh roasted (seasonal) $ 20
Pumpkin w/pecan - fresh roasted (seasonal) $23
(our traditional pumpkin with pecan crumble)
Raspberry $ 25
(crumb or traditional topped)
Raspberry Chèvre $ 28
(w/candied almond crumb topping)
Rhubarb (seasonal) $ 18
(crumb or traditional topped)
Southern Gentleman $ 23
(cherries and blackberry blend - crumb or traditional topped)
Strawberry, baked $ 18
(crumb or traditional topped)
Strawberry Rhubarb (seasonal) $ 20
(crumb or traditional topped)
Triple Berry $ 25
(blackberries, blueberries and raspberries w/crumb topping)
Gluten-Free Pies
We are able to make most of our pies in a Gluten-Free option. While we do try to keep a limited supply of ready-to-bake Gluten-Free pies in the freezer, we recommend placing a special-order for your Gluten-Free request. All special orders require a minimum of 48 hours prior notice.
GF Crust - add $5 to regular price of pie
GF top & bottom crust - add $10 to regular price of pie
We can make any quiche Gluten-Free - add $5
Cream Pies
Ambrosia Pie $ 20
(graham crust filled w/homemade whipped topping blend, w/pineapples, maraschino cherries, mandarin oranges, coconut and pecans)
Banana Cream $ 18
(w/homemade whipped topping)
Banana Coconut Cream $ 20
(w/homemade whipped topping)
Blueberry Cream $ 20
(homemade vanilla cream pie with fresh blueberries folded in, topped w/homemade whipped topping)
Butterscotch Cream $ 19
(w/homemade whipped topping)
Chocolate Cream $ 18
(w/homemade whipped topping)
Chocolate-Coconut Cream $ 20
(w/homemade whipped topping)
Coconut Cream $ 18
(w/homemade whipped topping)
German Chocolate $ 19
Killer Key Lime $ 20
(our traditional Key lime with REAL key lime juice from Key West)
Lula's Lemonade Cream $ 18
(graham crust filled with a light, tart whipped organic lemonade cream, topped w/homemade whipped cream and candied almonds)
Oreo Cream $ 19
Peanut Butter Cream $ 20
(w/chocolate ganache on graham crust)
Psycho Killer Key Lime $ 22
(same traditional recipe as our Key Lime, but add toasted coconut and pecans!)
S’Mores Pie $ 19
(graham crust filled w/marshmallow cream, topped w/marshmallows and drizzled w/ chocolate ganache)
Strawberry Cream Pie $ 21
(homemade vanilla cream pie with fresh strawberries folded in, topped w/homemade whipped topping)
Sugar Cream Pie $ 18
The Patriot (seasonal) $ 25
(vanilla cream topped w/homemade whipped cream, topped with seasonal fresh berries)
Vanilla Cream $ 18
(w/homemade whipped topping)
Savory
Bacon Quiche (swiss or cheddar cheese) $ 17
Broccoli Cheddar Quiche $ 17
Corned Beef Quiche (w/swiss cheese) $ 20
Dego Pie $ 18
(parmesan black pepper pie crust stuffed w/fresh Chèvre, tomatoes, garlic shallot and spices)
Ham Quiche (swiss or cheddar cheese) $ 17
Spicy Mexi Quiche $ 18
(Chorizo, onion, tomato, fresh jalapeno, 3 cheeses)
Veggie Quiche $ 17
(tomato, spinach, onion, asparagus & cheddar)
** Make any Quiche Gluten-Free - add $5
** Make any Quiche a Frittata! (no crust)
Ask about our Slab Pies!
They are a great party addition as they feed 18-24.
